By: Wendy O.
I took a course a few semesters ago that focused primarily on the evolution of simple organisms. This was towards the beginning of my biology career, and every course I have taken since then has built onto what was learned in that basic evolution course. We would not be here today if it were not for evolution, so it is paramount for scientists of any field to know at least the basics.
Evolution is a fascinating subject, but it is highly complex. Everyone has heard of it, yet few actually understand what is going on. For example, most have heard the phrase “survival of the fittest.” It is the main concept of natural selection. It sounds easy enough to understand: the fittest will survive, and the weak will die. This is all true, yet when it is used by most to justify something, it is usually used in the wrong way. I blame the scientists who coined this phrase for using too common of terms, which leads to confusion. The problem with the phrase is the word “fittest.” We use the word “fit” in everyday English to describe something that is in good physical shape. However, fitness actually means how well suited an organism is to its environment, and if it can produce offspring. It has nothing to do with how long it can run on a treadmill. Think about it this way: if “survival of the fittest” was all about how physically strong an organism was, wouldn’t big, carnivorous organisms such as the Tryanosaurus be around today, and small insects such as the cockroach be extinct?
Evolution is a tough subject to learn, which is one reason for all of the misunderstandings. Another reason is that it is a controversial subject too, so those misunderstandings are not always cleared up. For whatever the reason, it is a fundamental concept that should be understood by all at least at the basic level. Here is a list of some misconceptions of evolution, along with a brief description:
1. Origin of Life
It is often thought that evolution is a theory that explains how life begun on earth, but evolution, and its many theories, focus on how life changes and how it changed after life had begun.
2. Always Getting Better
The most well known theory of evolution is evolution by natural selection. This theory deals with the previously mentioned “survival of the fittest” means of adaptation and evolution. A common misconception that stems from this theory is that species, as some adapt and survive and others die out, those that survive must in some way be better than the ones that died out. This is not true, the ones that survived were simply more suited to that particular environment, at that particular time. In another environment, the organisms that died out may be the ones who now survive. The idea of natural selection has everything to do with environment, and nothing to do with progress.
3. Mutation is Bad
Without genetic mutation, all organisms of a given species would be exactly the same. All of the individuals of a population would have the same weaknesses, and could all be wiped out by a single cause. Mutation allows for some organisms to have an advantage over others, such as the ability to resist certain diseases.
4. Natural Selection Gives an Organism What it Needs
I hear this one a lot, even by so called “credible sources.” One example would be, mammals that live in cold environments need thick fur to survive, so natural selection gave these organisms the gene needed to grow thick fur. The problem with this logic is that evolution by natural selection doesn’t care what an organism needs. I need a Chanel purse, but natural selection still has not given one to me. What happens is: the organisms with the gene for thick fur will survive and reproduce (they have a high level of fitness), passing on the genes for thick fur .The organisms without the thick fur gene will die, will not produce offspring, and will not pass on any genes for non-thick fur. It is important to remember that natural selection is not a living thing. Therefore, it does not know when to give an organism something to ensure its survival.
5. Evolution is a Random Process
The process of evolution can be quite unpredictable at times, but for the most part it is quite systematic. The idea that evolution occurs haphazardly stems from the fact that genetic mutation, the source for variation among organisms, occurs at random. Natural selection, on the other hand, has a mechanism to it. It does not occur by chance that some organisms live, while others die. Many factors are involved, such as an organisms adaptability to a particular environment, the ability to produce offspring, and the ability to pass on favorable traits to those offspring.
6. Disparity Among Fossil Records Discredit the Theory
We can see the transition of organisms through fossil records, but sometimes there are no fossils to be found of an organism in one stage of its evolution. This gap does not disprove anything, all it proves is that the conditions were not met to make a fossil. Scientists can actually predict when there will be a gap in the fossil record. It is also important to remember that there are many transitional fossils that have been found, such as the fossils of organisms that show the transition from prehistoric dinosaurs to modern day birds.
There are lots of misconceptions out there, these are just a few. Let me know in the comments section if there are any you would like added to the list.
Thank you MFS for the suggestions!
Stumble it!